Why I’m Almost Afraid to Watch the Anthony Bourdain Movie

Kitchen Confidential told the truth about a world I knew intimately. I’m not sure I want to watch Hollywood clean it up. Photo by Jassir Jonis on Unsplash I should be excited about Tony , the new film about Anthony Bourd...

Kitchen Confidential told the truth about a world I knew intimately. I’m not sure I want to watch Hollywood clean it up.

Photo by Jassir Jonis on Unsplash

I should be excited about Tony, the new film about Anthony Bourdain.

I’m a former chef. I started young, worked in Michelin-starred and hatted kitchens, and Kitchen Confidential was one of the only books I had read from beginning to end through choice by the time I was 21.

I didn’t just finish it. I couldn’t put the bloody thing down.

So you would think I would be lining up to see the film.

I watched the trailer and had an immediate, physical reaction.

The clean chef whites. The handsome, kitchen brigade.

It looked romantic. It looked rosy.

It felt false and slightly icky.

Someone said to me, “Surely they can manage a more realistic depiction of being a chef than Monica in Friends.”

LOL. You would certainly hope so.

The book my father gave me

My father read Kitchen Confidential before I did and then gave me his copy. I was about 18 or 19 and had already worked in serious kitchens.

No one in my family on either side had worked in hopitality.

How do you explain that world to someone who has never been inside it?

You can describe the hours, the heat and the pressure. You can tell them about the burns, the drinking, the drugs, the egos and the brutal hierarchy. You can try to explain mise en place, the rituals, the hiding places, the kitchen cloths and all the little habits that become completely normal to the people doing the job.

But they still don’t really understand.

I was so happy that my dad had read Bourdain’s book because I thought perhaps, finally, he had caught a glimmer of it. Someone else had found the language for a life I didn’t know how to explain.

I’m dyslexic and I’m a slow reader. At that age, between working, being permanently tired and everything else, I hadn’t read many books all the way through.

Page after page, I kept thinking: Oh my God, I do that. Yes, that happens.

It wasn’t a glamorous book about becoming a chef. It was recognition.

They should look more like the cast of Trainspotting

I realise I am making assumptions about a film I haven’t seen. Perhaps it will prove me completely wrong.

But a trailer is a film asking you to watch it, and this trailer made me go: Fuck No!

The casting itself feels like nonsense.

I’m not saying chefs cannot be attractive. These days, plenty of chefs train, work out and take care of themselves…working conditions have improved …The hours are generally not as brutal as those I experienced or those Bourdain described.

But that is not the period this film is depicting.

The chefs I remember from that world didn’t look like Hollywood’s current collection of handsome men. Most of them looked like fucking junkies because many of them were so thin and exhausted. They had black rings under their eyes. They were burned, cut, dehydrated and surviving on cigarettes, adrenaline and whatever came after service.

They should look less like a collection of leading men and more like the cast of Trainspotting.

And the chef whites? Yes, they went on clean. Proper chefs take enormous pride in cleanliness. But if you were genuinely working in that kind of kitchen, the whites didn’t remain spotless. Halfway through service they carried marks from the work you had actually been doing. People had burns. People sweated. People looked tired.

We didnt have time for meaningful conversations .The work was repetitive, physical, precise and relentless. Communication was often reduced to the fewest words possible or to no words at all.

Where the misfits found one another

I came from one world and the kitchen dropped me into every world at once.

The people I worked beside came from every conceivable background. Some had exceptional educations; some had barely been given an education at all, Some had money some didn’t, Some arrived in the country as doctors, executives or other highly qualified professionals and ended up washing dishes because their qualifications or visas were not recognised. We came from different classes, countries, cultures and families. Sometimes whole groups of us did not share a language.

Yet under pressure, we found a way to communicate.

We had all arrived for different reasons, but many of us shared one thing: we did not necessarily fit anywhere else.

The kitchen was its own unwieldy acronym long before acronyms started acquiring a T, then a Q, then a plus and an I. We were the collection of letters that meant: Where the fuck do we put this one?

Put them somewhere their intensity, strangeness, obsessive habits, quick temper, dark humour or inability to sit still might actually be useful. Give them an impossible service to get through together and see what happens.

What happened was that we became connected.

Not necessarily in the sentimental sense, not that there wasn’t deep affection too, but because a great kitchen runs like a well-oiled machine. Every person is connected to the next. What I do directly affects your section; what you do determines whether the next person succeeds or goes down. Every cog depends on every other cog turning at exactly the right moment.

Some of the people with whom I felt the strongest connection and from whom I received the fiercest loyaltybarely shared a spoken language with me.

We did not need many words. Actions were enough.We went into battle together every night.

Service is like a war: a strategic attack planned through mise en place and executed under pressure. Everyone has a position. Everyone depends on the people beside them. You either do your part or somebody else has to absorb the impact.

You learn very quickly who will hold their position, who will see that you are going down and step across to help without being asked, and who you can trust when the whole thing is in danger of collapsing. That kind of trust does not require friendship in the conventional sense. It is built through hundreds of services in which your actions say: I have your back.

The bonds I formed in those kitchens have never really been matched, repeated or bettered.

That is what Kitchen Confidential understood. Kitchens were not compelling merely because they were chaotic, naughty or full of drugs. They were places where an unlikely collection of people could recognise and rely upon one another. Under pressure, background mattered less than whether you showed up, did your mise en place, held your position and could be trusted when everything went to shit.

Please don’t turn it into a costume

My concern is not simply that the saucepan is wrong or an actor’s knife technique looks a bit dodgy. Anyone who has worked in an industry will find technical faults when Hollywood depicts it.

This feels more fundamental.

Kitchen Confidential mattered because Bourdain did not make that world respectable before presenting it to us. He didn’t clean everybody up, give the chaos a sentimental purpose or turn the kitchen into an attractive backdrop for self-discovery.

He told the truth about its brutality, dysfunction, skill, ego, physical punishment, black humour, pride and astonishing loyalty.

The new film is reportedly a loose interpretation of one summer in Bourdain’s youth rather than a literal adaptation of his life. The estate has supported it, and the filmmakers may have created something very good on its own terms.

But the trailer makes it look as though that unruly awakening has been reshaped into a handsome coming-of-age story, complete with a charismatic fictional chef-mentor and a romantic thread.

That may make a more satisfying film. It may also wash away the very thing that made Bourdain’s writing extraordinary.

Why I’m taking it personally

I didn’t watch a great deal of Bourdain’s television work when it originally aired. I was a chef. When exactly was I supposed to be watching television about restaurants? While other people were discovering kitchens through him, I was already inside one.

My connection to Bourdain was not primarily as a television personality or celebrity. It was as the writer who described my world so accurately that, for once, I felt someone outside it might understand.

That is why I am taking a film trailer strangely personally.

There is another, more uncomfortable layer to that identification.

Anthony Bourdain took his own life. I would never pretend to know why. A death like that cannot be neatly explained by kitchens, addiction, fame, a relationship or any other single piece of a person’s life.

But I do know what it is to leave kitchens without kitchens ever quite leaving you.

I have PTSD. People assume it came from the kitchen. Perhaps some of it did. My life is no longer there, but that does not mean everything the life did to me has disappeared. Nor does it stop me missing some of the very things that may have damaged me.

The brutality. The rush. The camaraderie. The feeling that everything matters urgently and absolutely for the next few hours. The peculiar intimacy of relying on people completely and being relied upon in return.

Some of us remain addicts long after we stop taking the obvious drugs. We need the kitchen or at least what the kitchen gave us. When the adrenaline, danger, exhaustion and belonging disappear, where does all that need go?

Bourdain escaped the kitchen and built an extraordinary second life. He became successful beyond anything most chefs could imagine. But I sometimes wonder whether success can scratch the same itch. I wonder whether the person who has learned to survive through intensity ever becomes completely comfortable without it.

That is not an explanation for his death. It is a question I recognise in myself.

I am not only protective of Anthony Bourdain. I am protective of the truth he toldand of the part of my own life contained inside it.

Friends have already said, “We should go and see this. You’ll love it.”

I don’t think I will.

Perhaps I will eventually watch it and discover that I was unfair. I genuinely hope the film has more dirt, damage and truth in it than the trailer suggests.

But Bourdain did not make kitchens compelling by polishing them. He made them compelling by telling the fucking truth.

And I’m not sure I want to watch Hollywood clean it all away.