Stick, Twist or Bust?
Is now really a shit time to sell your café, or could waiting another year cost you more?
Interest rates are up. Wages are up. Food costs are up. And if you believe everything you read, the Australian hospitality industry is somewhere between having a bad year and falling off a cliff.
So, if you own a café, bakery or restaurant and you've been thinking about selling, what do you do?
Sell now, while there's still money on the table?
Or hang on for another year, hope things improve and see what 2027 brings?
Stick or twist?
It's a question I'm hearing more often, and having spent over 25 years working in hospitality before becoming a business broker, I understand why it's not an easy one to answer.
But here's the thing.
A difficult hospitality market doesn't automatically mean it's a bad time to sell your business.
And a better economy next year doesn't automatically mean your business will be worth more.
First, is it really all doom and gloom?
Let's not pretend the industry isn't doing it tough.
In November 2026, the Reserve Bank raised the cash rate to 4.85%. Inflation remains stubborn, operating costs are under pressure and many hospitality businesses have been absorbing increases they simply can't keep passing on to customers.
But Australians haven't stopped going out.
ABS figures for September showed spending at hotels, cafés and restaurants increasing by 0.5% over the month in nominal terms. That's not evidence of a booming industry, and higher prices account for some of that spending, but it isn't a picture of consumers abandoning hospitality either.
The reality is much less dramatic than the headlines.
Some businesses are struggling. Others are holding their own. Some are performing exceptionally well.
And that distinction matters enormously when it comes to selling.
Buyers haven't disappeared. But their expectations have changed.
One of the biggest misconceptions about selling a hospitality business is that its value is determined by how much the owner loves it, how busy it looks on Saturday morning or how much money they spent fitting it out.
Unfortunately, buyers don't see it that way.
They want to understand what they're purchasing.
How much money does it make? How much does the owner work? How secure is the lease? What happens when the current owner walks out the door?
In a cautious market, those questions become even more important.
A profitable, well-run business with reliable financial records, a sensible rent and a good lease can still make a compelling acquisition.
A beautiful café with questionable financials, an expensive lease and an owner working 70 hours a week?
That's a different conversation.
The market isn't necessarily rejecting hospitality businesses. It's being more selective about which businesses justify their asking prices.
The danger of waiting for a better market
Let's imagine your café currently makes $180,000 a year in adjusted owner earnings.
For illustration, a buyer might value that business at 1.6 times earnings, or $288,000.
You decide to wait another year because you're convinced the market will improve.
And perhaps it does.
Perhaps buyers become more confident and a comparable business could attract 1.8 times earnings.
Sounds good, doesn't it?
Except your wages, rent and food costs have continued to climb, and your earnings have fallen to $150,000.
At 1.8 times earnings, your business is now worth $270,000.
The market improved. Your business value went backwards.
These multiples are illustrative, not a market-wide valuation benchmark, but they demonstrate something owners often overlook.
Waiting isn't a neutral decision.
You are betting that improvements in buyer confidence will outweigh any deterioration in your business, lease, equipment or personal circumstances.
Sometimes that's a very good bet.
Sometimes it isn't.
Of course, selling now isn't always the answer either
There are plenty of businesses I wouldn't recommend taking to market immediately.
Perhaps you've only just opened and haven't established sustainable profitability.
Perhaps you've invested heavily in equipment or renovations but haven't yet seen the financial return.
Perhaps you're in the middle of improving your wage structure, renegotiating your lease or putting a management team in place.
In those circumstances, another 12 months could make an enormous difference.
Not necessarily because the economy improves, but because you've made the business better.
And that's the distinction I'd encourage every owner to understand.
Are you waiting for the market to change?
Or are you actively doing something that will improve the value of your business?
Because those are two very different strategies.
What would make your business worth more next year?
If you're going to hold, have a plan.
A buyer isn't going to pay more simply because another year has passed.
But they might pay more if you've:
- Improved your sustainable profit without relying on unpaid owner labour.
- Secured a longer, more attractive lease.
- Reduced your dependency on the owner being there every day.
- Built reliable systems, financial reporting and an experienced team.
- Demonstrated consistent trading rather than one unusually strong quarter.
These are changes a buyer can evaluate, and in many cases, they're more important than waiting for interest rates to come down.
Don't forget what another year costs you
There's another part of this conversation that rarely appears in a valuation spreadsheet.
Your life.
If you love running your business, you're making good money and still have the energy to do it, fantastic.
But if you're exhausted, missing weekends with your family or simply ready for something else, the decision isn't purely financial.
What is another year of your life worth?
I've spent enough time operating hospitality businesses to know that the personal cost can be substantial.
And sometimes the best decision isn't squeezing every possible dollar out of the eventual sale.
It's recognising when you're ready to move on.
So, stick or twist?
Here's how I'd look at it.
Sell now if the business is performing well, the financials are credible, your lease is attractive and you're genuinely ready to move on.
Hold and improve if there are specific, achievable changes that could increase the value over the next 6–12 months.
Keep operating if you love what you're doing, the returns justify the work and selling isn't part of your immediate plans.
But if your entire strategy is to wait for the market to magically improve, I'd challenge that.
Because none of us knows exactly what the market will look like in 12 months.
And even if conditions improve, your business might not be in a better position to take advantage of them.
Before you make the decision, know your number.
You don't have to put your café on the market just because you're curious about its value.
In fact, I'd argue that understanding what your business might realistically sell for should come well before deciding whether to sell.
A proper appraisal isn't about pulling a multiple out of thin air and telling you what you want to hear.
It's about understanding the business, the financials, the lease, the likely buyer and the obstacles that could affect a sale.
Sometimes that conversation ends with a decision to sell.
Sometimes it ends with a plan to improve the business and revisit things in a year.
And sometimes the best advice I can give an owner is to stay exactly where they are.
But at least they're making that decision with their eyes open.
So, is now really a shit time to sell your café?
Not necessarily.
It might be a terrible time to sell your particular café.
Or it might be exactly the right time.
The important thing is knowing the difference.
Olivia Casson is a Sydney hospitality business broker and former chef and operator with more than 25 years' experience in the industry. Through Casson Hospitality, she specialises in helping owners of cafés, bakeries, restaurants and bars understand, prepare for and navigate a business sale.