Part 2: The Human Cost of Perfect Food

Photo by Paulette Vautour on Unsplash We Knew. We Just Preferred Not to Look Too Closely. Kitchen trauma became entertainment long before it became scandal. This is Part 2 of a series on fine dining, abuse, accountabilit...

Photo by Paulette Vautour on Unsplash

We Knew. We Just Preferred Not to Look Too Closely.

Kitchen trauma became entertainment long before it became scandal.

This is Part 2 of a series on fine dining, abuse, accountability and the human cost of perfect food.

In Part 1, I asked whether you can build three-star food without breaking people.

In this part, I want to ask something different.

Did the public, the media and the food world really not know kitchens were like this?
Or did we know, and then perform shock when the real version became too public to ignore?

The outrage is valid.

If people have been bullied, humiliated, harassed, threatened or abused, there should be consequences. People in power should be held accountable. Victims should be heard, protected and taken seriously.

But what I struggle with is the speed of the moral distancing.

The same world that celebrated these chefs, photographed them, interviewed them, awarded them, invited them, toasted them and dined out on their names suddenly wants to act like it had no idea what kind of culture it was standing next to.

I do not buy it.

Vaughan Mabee is one of the current names in the headlines. Amisfield had been one of New Zealand’s most celebrated restaurants before Cuisine removed it from its 2025 Good Food Guide following misconduct allegations against Mabee.

But this is not only about Mabee.

It is not only about René Redzepi, Noma, Swillhouse, Restaurant Hubert, or whichever name happens to be in the headline that week.

The details are different. The allegations are different. The level of accountability is different. Every case should be treated on its own facts.

But the pattern is familiar.

The industry celebrates the genius, the status and the access while it is useful, then rushes to distance itself when the damage becomes public.

In Sydney, Restaurant Hubert was removed from Gourmet Traveller’s guide after misconduct allegations involving Swillhouse were reported.

Australian readers do not need to look overseas to understand the pattern.

Guides, awards, celebrity chefs, glossy profiles, restaurant groups, launch parties, canapé events, impossible bookings and people desperate to say they were first in.

Food media did not just report on this culture.

It dined out on it.

TV production companies built shows around it.

Presenters stood beside it.

Journalists interviewed it.

Glossy magazines photographed it.

Guidebooks awarded it.

We loved the volatile genius chef, or the entrepreneur with the Midas touch, when they were pouring champagne, plating canapés and giving interviews.

It only became unacceptable when the damage became public.

That is the part that feels dishonest.

Maybe people did not know every allegation.

Maybe they did not know every victim.

Maybe they did not know every detail.

But we knew enough.

And we celebrated it while it was useful.

That is not accountability.

That is reputational hygiene.

The culture was never hidden

Boiling Point was one of the most realistic depictions of kitchen pressure I have seen on screen. Not necessarily Michelin-kitchen specific, but absolutely recognisable to anyone who has worked through a proper high-pressure service.

The shouting.

The pressure.

The noise.

The panic.

The constant sense that everything is about to fall apart.

It was hard to watch because it was not ridiculous.

It was familiar.

Then there is The Bear.

I did not personally like it, but people did. It made kitchen trauma look cool. Better lighting. Better music. Better styling. Smarter dialogue.

People shouting “Yes, Chef” and “Chef’s kiss” was enough to make me wish the show was cancelled.

People were missing the fucking point.

Hell’s Kitchen has also remained commercially strong enough to be renewed through seasons 25 and 26.

Not seasons 1 and 2.

Seasons 25 and 26.

So when the public now acts shocked that kitchens can be brutal, I struggle with that.

Because we knew enough.

We watched it.

Then we quoted it.

Then we bought the apron.

Then we booked the restaurant.

Then, when the real version became too ugly to ignore, we performed shock.

This is not only about kitchens

We know environment changes behaviour because we watch it for entertainment.

Reality TV has built a global market around isolating people, removing normal routines, controlling information, creating pressure and seeing what happens.

Shows like Big Brother, Survivor, Love Island and Married at First Sight do not work because people behave normally.

They work because people are taken out of normal life, placed under pressure, watched, judged, rewarded and punished.

We like watching people under pressure.

We like watching what happens when normal life is stripped away.

We like watching people compete, unravel, perform, fight, cry, recover, apologise, fail and come back.

But the mechanism is not imaginary.

Remove sleep.

Remove privacy.

Remove outside perspective.

Add status.

Add pressure.

Add public judgment.

Add reward and punishment.

People change.

Reality TV turned that into a format.

Fine dining turned it into a career.

That does not excuse it.

We wanted the theatre too

We wanted the impossible booking.

The chef’s table.

The bragging rights.

The chance to be first in.

The chance to know the chef.

To call him a friend.

To be at the launch, the soft opening, the table everyone else could not get.

And I understand that.

I love food. I love restaurants. I love excellence. I understand why people are drawn to it.

But we need to stop pretending the plate arrives without a human cost.

Kitchen trauma was not hidden.
It was a dirty little secret dressed up as entertainment, excellence and genius.

And this is why some of the public outrage feels hollow.

Not because the behaviour is acceptable.

It is not.

But because outrage is easy once the story is public.

Maybe we were not shocked because we did not know.

Maybe we were embarrassed.

Maybe we were guilty.

Maybe the real shock is not that these kitchens existed.

Maybe the real shock is that so many people benefited from pretending not to understand what they were looking at.