Are All Hospitality Business Brokers Created Equal? Why Industry Experience Matters

I’ve spent most of my career spinning plates. I just didn’t expect to be doing it as a business broker. If you’ve ever worked a busy Friday night service in hospitality, you’ll know a thing or two about spinning plates....

I’ve spent most of my career spinning plates. I just didn’t expect to be doing it as a business broker.

If you’ve ever worked a busy Friday night service in hospitality, you’ll know a thing or two about spinning plates.

The kitchen’s behind. Someone’s called in sick. Table 12 has an allergy. The dishwasher’s broken. A delivery hasn’t arrived, and there’s a customer demanding to speak to the manager.

And somehow, you’ve got to keep the whole thing moving.

That’s hospitality.

Whether you’ve spent your career in kitchens, behind bars, managing restaurant floors or running entire operations, you get very good at juggling problems, managing people and making decisions under pressure.

And there are a LOT of plates to spin.

Interestingly, selling a hospitality business isn’t all that different.

Except now the plates are buyers, vendors, accountants, solicitors, landlords and banks.

Everyone has different priorities. Everyone wants an answer yesterday. And one dropped plate can bring the whole thing crashing down.

Which brings me to a question.

Are all hospitality business brokers created equal?

Absolutely not.

But I think the more interesting question is whether you can truly understand the business you’re selling if you’ve never actually worked in the industry.

You can read a P&L. But do you understand what’s behind it?

You can learn how to value a business, read financial statements, negotiate a sale and advertise a listing.

But understanding what actually happens inside a hospitality business is something else entirely.

Two restaurants can have exactly the same turnover and be completely different businesses.

One has a working owner doing 60 hours a week. The other has a management team in place.

One has an efficient menu, sensible staffing and systems that allow the business to function without the owner being there every minute.

The other has a complicated menu, high labour costs and a chef-owner holding everything together through sheer determination.

On paper, they might look similar.

Operationally, they’re worlds apart.

And that’s quite important when you’re trying to establish what someone should pay for them.

I was a chef long before I became a broker

I started my career in kitchens.

Over the past 25-plus years, I’ve worked my way into senior operational and leadership roles with some of the biggest and most successful restaurant groups across Europe, Australia and internationally.

I’ve opened venues, managed large teams, been responsible for commercial performance and been brought in to turn around businesses that weren’t working.

For years, I was the person sent in when something needed fixing.

Sometimes that meant improving profitability. Sometimes rebuilding teams, changing menus, restructuring operations or working out why a venue with enormous turnover wasn’t actually making any money.

And quite often, the answer wasn’t sitting neatly in a spreadsheet.

It was in the operation.

The rostering. The purchasing. The workflow. The management structure. The systems. The people.

You learn an awful lot when you’re the person responsible for making those things work.

And that experience doesn’t suddenly become irrelevant because I’ve moved into business brokerage.

Quite the opposite.

I don’t just look at what a business makes. I look at how it makes it.

When I walk into a café or restaurant, I’m looking at considerably more than the décor.

I’m looking at the kitchen layout, the equipment, the workflow, the staffing and how the business actually operates.

If it’s a café doing substantial coffee volume, I’m thinking about how many people it takes to produce that volume, whether the wage structure makes sense and how the team is organised.

If it’s a restaurant, I’m looking at the menu, kitchen staffing, production requirements and how dependent the operation is on particular people.

Someone with a strong front-of-house background might immediately notice service inefficiencies, staffing problems or missed opportunities to increase revenue.

A bar operator might recognise issues with licensing, beverage margins, stock control or the realities of late-night trading.

Different hospitality backgrounds bring different perspectives.

And those perspectives matter.

Because there’s a difference between calculating profitability and understanding whether it’s sustainable.

Take a café showing a healthy owner’s benefit.

Fantastic.

But the owner works 55 hours a week.

What are they actually doing during those hours?

Making coffee? Cooking? Managing the floor? Ordering stock? Handling administration? Covering shifts because they’re short-staffed?

If a buyer wants to run that business under management, who replaces those 55 hours?

Can one person realistically do it?

Or are we now talking about employing a chef and a manager?

Because that changes the numbers considerably.

You can’t just take wages out of a spreadsheet and assume the work disappears.

Someone still has to do the job.

And it’s exactly these sorts of things that can become major issues during due diligence if nobody has thought about them beforehand.

Then there’s the business of actually selling it

This is where all those years of spinning plates really come into play.

Finding someone interested in buying a business is only part of the job.

Getting them from that first enquiry through negotiations, due diligence, contract exchange and eventually settlement is another matter entirely.

And there are a remarkable number of moving parts.

The vendor wants to move on.

The buyer wants reassurance.

The accountant wants another breakdown of wages.

The solicitor wants a clause amended.

The landlord wants additional guarantees.

The bank wants evidence that the business can support the loan.

Meanwhile, the buyer is getting nervous, the vendor is getting frustrated and everyone thinks somebody else is holding things up.

Sound familiar?

It’s not unlike running a busy restaurant.

Everyone has their own priorities, but the entire operation still needs to work together.

And someone needs to keep it moving.

A good broker needs to understand the commercial issues, manage those competing demands and recognise when something is starting to go wrong.

Sometimes that means pushing back on an unreasonable request.

Sometimes it’s having an uncomfortable conversation with a vendor.

Sometimes it’s recognising that the buyer who asks a hundred questions is actually the serious one, while the person promising to pay full asking price tomorrow hasn’t got the money.

And sometimes it’s simply stopping someone from sending an email they’ll regret.

A good broker doesn’t just negotiate a deal. They spend an enormous amount of time stopping perfectly good deals from falling apart.

Often, the vendor never even knows those conversations happened.

And that’s probably how it should be.

The uncomfortable conversations are part of the job

One thing I’ve never particularly enjoyed, but have become very comfortable doing, is telling people things they don’t want to hear.

I’ve done it throughout my operational career.

And I do it now.

Sometimes a business isn’t worth what the owner thinks it is.

Sometimes the profit depends on an unrealistic amount of unpaid owner labour.

Sometimes the wage structure doesn’t make sense.

Sometimes the systems are excellent, but the accounts don’t communicate the business’s operational strengths particularly well.

And sometimes there are problems that really should be addressed before the business goes to market.

I’d much rather have those conversations at the beginning.

Because telling a vendor their business is worth an unrealistic amount simply to win the listing doesn’t help anyone.

You might get the business on your books.

But can you actually sell it?

And if someone does make an offer, will that price survive due diligence?

That’s the difference between getting an offer and getting a business sold.

Does that mean every hospitality professional would make a great broker?

Of course not.

I’ve worked with some exceptional chefs, managers and operators who would probably find business brokerage an absolute nightmare.

And there are excellent business brokers who have never worked a day in a commercial kitchen.

The skills aren’t automatically interchangeable.

Business brokerage requires an understanding of valuations, negotiation, finance, commercial leases, buyer qualification and the processes involved in getting a transaction completed.

It also takes patience, persistence and a fairly high tolerance for people doing things that make absolutely no sense.

Hospitality probably prepares you quite well for that last one.

But I do think combining genuine operational experience with strong brokerage skills brings something particularly valuable to the table.

Because you’re not just selling a set of numbers.

You’re selling an operating business with people, equipment, systems, commitments, risks and opportunities.

And you need to understand what all of those things mean to whoever is going to take it over.

So, are all hospitality business brokers created equal?

No.

And I don’t think choosing one should come down to whoever gives you the highest appraisal or promises to sell your business the quickest.

I’d want someone who understands what they’re selling.

Someone who can look beyond the financial statements and recognise what’s happening operationally.

Someone who knows which questions buyers are likely to ask, can spot potential problems before they derail a deal and is prepared to challenge unrealistic expectations.

And someone who can keep all those plates spinning when the transaction starts getting complicated.

Because believe me, it will.

I’ve spent most of my career working in an industry where the individual plates matter, but keeping the entire operation moving is what makes it successful.

Selling a hospitality business isn’t so different.

You can learn how to sell a restaurant. Understanding what it actually takes to run one is a different education altogether.

And personally, having spent most of my working life doing both, I think there’s enormous value in that combination.

Olivia Casson is a Sydney hospitality business broker, former chef and hospitality operator with more than 25 years of experience. Her career includes senior leadership roles with major restaurant groups across Europe, Australia and internationally, specialising in venue openings, multi-site operations, commercial performance and business turnarounds.

Casson Hospitality | cassonhospitality.com